Why Threats Don’t Work


Nonviolent Communication / Wednesday, November 21st, 2018

Gaining children’s cooperation is a widely discussed topic in my clinic, and the strategy of threatening children always plays a big role. “Because it works!” they say. If it works, I ask, why are you here?

“Mommy’s leaving”!

“If you won’t stop doing that I’ll take <something you like> away”!

“If you won’t come with me now, we won’t be able to do <something you like>”!

“If you want <something you like> you must <do something you don’t like>”

Let’s be honest – we all do that. We’re used to doing that; we’re used to this sort of power-asserting sentences, and we’re used to them because they work. They push a trigger. They motivate kids to follow a required action. But why?

No More Tantrums

Children’s Cognitive Perception and Why Threats “Work”

We might want to think that a child’s brain functions the same way adults’ brain functions, but that is very far from the truth. Our little ones’ processing is incredibly different from the way we think; they see the world through a completely different lens. 

The frontal lobe, that part of the cortex that is responsible for our automatic responses, delayed gratification, and a variety of other functions, begins it’s development at birth, but is only fully developed towards the age of… 25! Yes, your eyes aren’t fooling you. 25. What does it mean about a 2.5 year old? Or a 3, 4 or 5 year old?

It means that children can only experience one emotion at a time; their emotions know no conflicts, whenever one emotion rises – it becomes the child’s full experience. This is the reason for which happy and content children throw massive tantrums within a second, and the same reason for which they are happy again as soon as that emotional train had passed, while we are still collecting pieces of our heart from all over the floor. Children’s’ emotions take turns, they cannot play together 🙂   

When our little one is playing at the park, she can’t care less about our commitments or other plans we might have made for the day. She’s at play, and there’s nothing we can do to change her mindset; this is usually when various threatening strategies are used.  

Why are Threats Effective in Gaining Children’s Cooperation? 

Although there are countless emotions one can experience, anxiety, urgency, and anger are our limbic system’s core emotions; these emotions are forever tied to our survival instinct, and, in order to keep us safe, are super easy to trigger. These core emotions are exactly what makes threats work. Just like all other emotions, these three cannot appear all at once, they will take their turns, too. But they are forever tied one to the other. Anxiety → urgency → anger.

Mindful parenting challenge

Threatening kids to gain their cooperation is a widespread practice; here's why it doesn't work and what to do instead. #AttachmentParenting #PositiveDiscipline #GentleParenting
Why threats should never be used as a strategy to gain children's cooperation

What do We Really Say when We Threaten a Child? 

Connection and attachment are existential human needs that play massive roles in children’s hearts and brains. When we threaten to leave, to leave them alone, to take something they are connected to, or to withdraw from an activity they are expecting, we threaten their connection to the ones they love most – us. A threatened connection, or rather – a threatened attachment, is likely to trigger a child to take action and remove herself from that situation. Thus – to join you and leave the park. Being a core emotion to the limbic system, fear and panic will always overrule all other emotions, even the desire to continue playing.

This is the reason for which threats “work”. But threatening your child will always come with a price, and this price is the reason for which we should revise our core concepts to child discipline

The Price We Pay for Cooperation through Threats

The effects of fear-driven discipline strategies are like shadows that follow us everywhere we go, and this is one of the first subjects I discuss with parents who join my online parent coaching. The underlying fear experienced by our little ones is in many cases the reason to behaviors we wish to alter. However, without knowing how their little brains work, we keep pushing the same buttons.

If your child is resistant, defiant and prone to power struggles, this might help you get things back on track.

Filters Sort results
Enhanced Parenting Course
Current Price
Parenting Course
$100.00$150.00
Enhanced Parenting Course

Filters Sort results
Online Parenting Seminars:
Current Price
Positive Parenting Seminar
$150.00
$300.00

When we gain our children’s cooperation using threats, what we see is the cooperation, but invisible to us is the limbic system’s response that triggers frustration and panic right after it triggers fear.

Violent reactions towards siblings or friends, clinginess, lack of self confidence, inability to fall asleep, resistance, defiance, and so many other responses are linked directly to the triggering of fear. Addressing these behaviors without addressing the underlying (and unmet) needs for connection, safety, and protection is futile. What we should do instead is remove fear is means to cooperation, as conditioning to attachment.

Connection and Attachment are the Strongest Motivators

Connection and attachment are the strongest motivating feelings. When operating from a point of compassion, we can expect the same in return. And it will be given to us gladly. Remembering that meeting the needs of our loved ones is a human need in and off itself is an amazing tool to measure connection. If our little one isn’t cooperating – it usually means that something disturbed the connection – and that’s what we’ll need to focus on.   

It won’t change everything on the spot, but this is indeed the only way to empower our little ones on this learning process called “Life”. Moreover – if we won’t teach our children that fear triggers people’s actions, they won’t be able to use it against others. And that brings us one step closer to a much better world, doesn’t it? 🙂

Join my parenting support group on Facebook, I would love to get to know you 🙂

Threatening children leads to much more than momentary cooperation. This is why it is a bad strategy, and quite a few ideas on what to do instead.
Filters Sort results

1 on 1 parent coaching

Viki de Lieme

Hi there! Welcome to my home 🙂 I am a mom, a parent educator, a Nonviolent Communication specialist, and attachment parenting advocate. I help children (and their parents) reconnect and find the joy of family life.

4 Replies to “Why Threats Don’t Work”

  1. Thank you for this article. I have question.
    Is it possible to give choice like instead of saying “I will stop the TV if you dont wear your glasses while watching it.”
    Can you say “You can choose between watching the TV with glasses on or not wearing your glasses and playing with something else, but no TV- sorry.”
    What do you think about that? Or is it still a threat… Thank you.

    1. Hi Gerie, for the example you’ve given I would go for “What’s it going to be? Glasses on and TV, or glasses off and a game”? I would advise losing the word “if” all entirely, as this one is usually the main part of a threat. Use short and clear sentences, no need to add “sorry” in the end as it confuses the little one. Let me know if you have more questions 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *